Case

Agnello v Hounslow BC [2003] EWHC 3112; [2003] NPC 158; [2004] BLGR 536

Bias; Local authorities powers and duties; Markets; Natural justice; Procedural impropriety; Tenants Local authorities powers and duties; markets; selection procedure for tenants; procedure tainted by bias and breach of natural justice A, a group of former tenants of market units, applied for judicial review of H's decision not to select them as tenants for a new smaller market which was to replace the existing market. H had set up a relocation committee, which comprised members of a tenants' association, T, to which A belonged, and members of H, to assist in the selection of tenants for the new market using specified criteria. A contended that the selection procedure was flawed in that (1) it involved unlawful delegation or abdication of H's decision making function to the relocation committee; (2) it was tainted by bias through the involvement of a small group of individuals who were members of T's board and who were direct competitors of A, and (3) it was procedurally unfair, since A was denied the opportunity to make representations about the application to them of the criteria for relocation to the new market. Click here for the judgment

Download your shortlist

Download All Download icon