High Court dismisses challenge to Brockwell Park festivals

An attempt to halt a series of music festivals at Brockwell Park in Lambeth, has been rejected by the High Court. The south London park is due to host several large-scale music events, starting in May, which attract hundreds of thousands of attendees each year.

Juliet Chambers, a local resident, brought a legal challenge against Lambeth Council, arguing that the authority had incorrectly interpreted the concept of “recreation” when approving use of part of the park for the events. This follows ongoing opposition to the festivals, with campaigners expressing concern about potential long-term damage to the park. The planning permission granted allows for a temporary change of use affecting part of the site for up to 32 days.

The claim was dismissed by Mr Justice Jay, who concluded that “recreation” includes activities undertaken for pleasure or interest, and that music festivals fall within the scope of cultural activity.

On behalf of Ms Chambers, Richard Harwood KC argued that the council’s grant of permission was “unlawful”. In response, Sasha White KC, representing Lambeth Council, submitted that the majority of the park, approximately 74%, would remain accessible to the public throughout the event period. He also noted that assessments had suggested no “unacceptable harm” as a result of the planning permission, and a number of benefits had been recognised.

Sasha White KC and Matthew Henderson acted for the London Borough of Lambeth.

Scott Stemp represented the festival promoters, Summer Events, who had previously been advised by Dr Ashley Bowes.